[unisog] Wireless in residence building - Tricky problem
tim at roughdraft.org
Wed Nov 5 21:54:53 GMT 2003
On Wed, Nov 05, 2003 at 01:50:59PM -0500, Bob Kalal wrote:
> What? The profs never noticed all the students reading the
> campus paper, browsing magazines, and using cell phones
> in the lecture hall?
Ah, very good -- this is PRECISELY one of the arguments we made. (Um,
and we included napping, an essential part of amphitheater life.) We
tried to steer it away from being a TECHNICAL discussion in the
direction of a real-life discussion: yes, there are cutoff switches for
APs, but not for newspapers/doodlers/snoozers/game-players/SMS
users/usw, so we attempted to put APs in the context of everything else
that could be a distraction.
But the technophobic lecturers carried the day. Fear, uncertainty, and
doubt won out. I don't know if the switches have gone in yet, but the
last I heard, the executive order was given to make it so. I hasten to
add that the security and networking people among us definitely saw it
as a no-brainer. But we did not carry the requisite academic weight.
> Well for that case I suppose you could fill the hall
> with water as a countermeasure. That would make the
> newspapers soggy & hard to read and probably short out
> the cell phones. hard to play a remote game on a shorted
> out cell.
You forgot pestilence. That always helps make a flood more fun any day.
As for the message that pointed out jamming in a public space
and how cell phones don't operate in the 2.4GHz range: I am sorry for
being unclear. I was conflating the issue of jamming an AP in a private
space (a lecture hall) with that of jamming cellular traffic in some
public space (a performance hall).
I agree that there might be any number of objections raised by cell
companies about jamming cell traffic. What surprised me was how the
topic never came up (that I recall) in the general discussion of what
to do about cell phones being used at the theater. I never thought
of what the FCC might have to say. The comments here about FCC
penalties were enlightening.
More information about the unisog