[unisog] DMCA Reports and No-Reply Addresses
cderr at simons-rock.edu
Fri Dec 31 01:46:05 GMT 2004
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
We haven't yet seen one from this company yet (we're a very small
school), but wouldn't it be possible to choose #3 and fill in whatever
information one has to indicate this is the case?
(aside -- if i wasn't the one that started to top-post, it's still
kosher to do it after it's been done once, right? -- also, do those
misconfigured vacation replies to this list strike anyone else as
so incredibly "ironic")
Allison MacFarlan wrote:
| It's ironic, or maybe not, that BayTSP has done this, because we've
| found that it's the least accurate or responsive company of any of
| the copyright-enforcement folks. Even if you've got a name and
| telephone number, you'll never get a response to a query about
| one of their complaints.
| However, I would caution anyone to reply to this questionnaire, because
| if you (the Security Operations Group) respond to this, you are assuming
| the legal burden of compliance, by saying that *you've* complied and
| removed the material. You can only say that "the material has been
| removed," based on information or indications you have of the
| student's compliance.
| This seems like an insidious way of forcing universities to assume a
| responsibility where they would normally have a safe harbor protection
| as a provider, not to mention the extra work created for those who've
| managed to automate these complaints.
| BTW, these are the mail addresses we have for BayTSP:
| paramount-picture at copyright-compliance.com
| mgm at copyright-compliance.com
| On Wednesday, Dec 29, 2004, at 18:55 US/Eastern, Eric Pancer wrote:
| It's almost 2005, and more games have started with the DMCA
| "enforcers." We received a notice today from BayTSP with the
| following "From" and "Reply-To" set:
| <universal-studios-no-reply at champ.baytsp.com>
| Replying to this address offers the following error.
| <universal-studios-no-reply at champ.baytsp.com>:
| Sorry, I couldn't find any host named champ.baytsp.com. (#5.1.2)
| Embedded in the email is the following blob:
| All correspondence regarding this notice should be sent to:
| Note that anyone can go to this page, no authentication is required.
| Then, you'll get to waste your time filling in the pretty boxes
| (note that you've already wasted your time by having to open up a
| browser since you don't use a graphical email client (you don't,
| right?)). The three options you can select are:
| 1. I've complied and removed all copyrighted material for which
| I'm not the copyright holder
| 2. No, I've not complied and I'm still distributing copyrighted
| 3. Mistake, You sent the notice to the wrong person (fill in more
| detail below).
| You'll then have to check a box that states...
| " By checking this box I swear that I have provided truthful
| So, for all of you that have automated processing of incoming DMCA
| reports, Happy New Year, and get to work on some automated things to
| select option #3 above using curl!
| Eric Pancer :.: Computer Security Response Team :.: DePaul University
| http://security.depaul.edu/ .:`:.:':.:`:. epancer at security.depaul.edu
| pgp: 1024D/7ACBCFF3 C022 4991 41E5 51E7 683C F765 62F7 7F8E 7ACB CFF3
unisog mailing list
unisog at lists.sans.org
| Allison S. MacFarlan
| Information Security Officer
| Academic Media and Technology
| Yale University
| ph: 203-432-6684
| bp: 203-370-0554
| unisog mailing list
| unisog at lists.sans.org
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.4 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the unisog